Book Review: What If YOU Are the Answer?: And 26 Other Questions Tha…
I can still recall the excitement I felt when I first discovered Rachel Hollis. This vibrant voice in self-help crafted a sense of community that resonated deeply within me. Her previous works, particularly “Girl, Wash Your Face,” were cornerstones on my bookshelf, serving as my pep talks through the ups and downs of life. Naturally, when I heard about her latest release, What If YOU Are the Answer?: And 26 Other Questions Tha…, I was eager to dive in, hoping to rekindle that spark of inspiration. Alas, my experience turned into a rather perplexing journey, ultimately leading me to a hard stop at 75%.
The premise of this new book seemed promising: a collection of reflections, actionable advice, and those trademark Hollis anecdotes. However, the delivery felt disjointed, appearing more like a compilation of previously shared thoughts rather than a cohesive narrative. As I read, I was struck by the stark contrast between my expectations and the reality of what unfolded on the pages.
From the outset, the book presents actionable insights that initially hooked me. One standout chapter focused on creating vision boards with friends, and it was indeed inspiring. It offered that exhilarating rush of motivation that I’ve come to associate with Hollis’ work. But soon after, the themes began to blur, leaving me puzzled. The advice felt scattered, exacerbated by contradictions that made me question the journey I was on with Hollis. For instance, one moment she’s urging us to shed the weight of others’ opinions, yet in later anecdotes, her struggles with this very issue have not seemed to dissipate since “Girl, Wash Your Face.”
The writing style, typically so vibrant and engaging, seemed to falter. Many chapters felt recycled; I stumbled upon stories I’d encountered before, presented now as if new revelations. In one breath, Hollis recounted the depth of her first panic attack, yet in the next, glossed over her past missteps as if she were oversimplifying the complexities of her journey. Rather than feel inspired, I found myself feeling somewhat gaslit, wrestling with the disconnect between the years of admiration I had for her authenticity and the curated portrait unfolding in this book.
Memorable quotes felt elusive—rather than profound, many statements passed by without the punch I craved. It became an experience akin to scrolling through an Instagram feed where the “candid” moments are polished and staged, leaving me yearning for that raw, real emotion that once characterized Hollis’ previous works.
As much as I wanted to champion this book, I’m left with the understanding that it may not resonate as deeply with others as it once did with me. For readers who are newer to Rachel Hollis, this collection might hold some refreshing insights, though those already familiar with her journey could feel a sense of repetition.
If you’re drawn to self-help that feels like a conversation with an old friend, you may find that Hollis still sparks some motivation. However, if you’re searching for the authentic, incisive wisdom that defined her earlier works, you might feel the same frustration I encountered. For me, this reading experience has been a mix of nostalgia and disillusionment, a reminder that not every beloved author can sustain the magic across every new release.
Discover more about What If YOU Are the Answer?: And 26 Other Questions Tha… on GoodReads >>