Review of The Eight Heartbreaks of Hanukkah by Jean Meltzer
As someone who has always been enchanted by stories that delve into the complexities of love and personal growth, I was immediately drawn to Jean Meltzer’s The Eight Heartbreaks of Hanukkah. I’ve admired Meltzer’s work ever since she burst onto the scene, intertwining poignant themes with authentic Jewish representation. The blend of holiday storytelling, deep-seated emotions, and relatable characters had all the ingredients for a captivating read. Little did I know just how much this book would resonate with me on so many levels.
The protagonist, Evelyn Schwartz, couldn’t be more relatable—especially during a season that often feels more festive and joyous than the reality many face. After a devastating split from her ex-husband, David Adler, during the very holiday she’s now supposed to celebrate, Evelyn is understandably a bit jaded. Yet, instead of wallowing, she channels her energy into her career, earning respect in the male-dominated world of television. But who hasn’t had that moment when the past comes creeping back in, just when you think you’ve moved on? David’s unexpected reentry into her life not only threw me for a loop but also brought to light unresolved feelings that I couldn’t help but root for them to explore.
Meltzer’s writing is so immersive; I felt as if I were swept into the narrative, gazing at the vibrant lights from the menorah beside Evelyn. The pacing was impeccable, allowing just enough time to savor the buildup while keeping the stakes thrillingly high. The ghosts of heartbreak that visit her throughout the eight nights of Hanukkah serve as poignant reminders that healing often requires revisiting old wounds. It’s a touching reminder that personal growth isn’t linear—and it’s often messy. The revelations woven through these visits added an emotional depth that was both cathartic and enlightening.
Among many delightful moments, one that particularly struck a chord was Evelyn’s journey with chronic migraines—a condition that can feel invisible to those who don’t experience it. As someone who has navigated her own health struggles, I especially appreciated how Meltzer captured the overwhelming battle of feeling unwell while looking fine on the outside. This kind of representation matters and is often overlooked.
Another standout character is Jared Sparks—Evelyn’s quirky yet lovable colleague. His presence added some much-needed comic relief, proving that laughter can be a salve amidst chaos. The connection and chemistry between Evelyn and David gave me butterflies, reminding me that love is often found in unexpected places, even within unresolved heartbreak.
Meltzer also tackles sensitive topics with grace—from Jewish perspectives on abortion to the profound grief of losing a child—making this story not only a love story but also a poignant exploration of the human experience. The mention of Baby Boy Chesney adds a haunting yet beautiful layer that will surely resonate with many readers, inviting reflection and empathy.
I wholeheartedly recommend The Eight Heartbreaks of Hanukkah to anyone who cherishes stories of personal resilience, complex relationships, and the intricate tapestry that is love wrapped in the warmth of tradition. Meltzer has crafted a tale that, while deeply personal and often painfully honest, ultimately pushes towards hope and redemption.
This book left me feeling uplifted and grateful for the intricate, imperfect web of our emotions and connections. So, gather your latkes and sufganiyot, and get ready for a journey of love that’s both healing and heartwarming.
Discover more about The Eight Heartbreaks of Hanukkah on GoodReads >>