Review of Much Ado About Hating You by A.R. Kahn: A Missed Opportunity in the Enemies-to-Lovers Trope
When I stumbled across the adorable and spicy cover of Much Ado About Hating You by A.R. Kahn, I was immediately charmed. The whimsical design promised a delightful enemies-to-lovers story infused with Shakespearean elements—what’s not to love? As someone who revels in witty banter and tension-filled narratives, I couldn’t resist diving into this modern retelling. However, what started as an enticing premise quickly devolved into one of the most disappointing reads I’ve encountered in a long time.
Set against a backdrop of academic rivalry, the story centers around Micah Mila and her professor, Aiden Scott. Despite the appealing setup, the characters fell flat, resembling nothing more than wet blankets with their dull dialogue and uninspired pranks. The “enemy” exchanges lacked any genuine passion, making it hard to root for them when their conflicts felt about as thrilling as watching paint dry. The insults tossed back and forth seemed more fitting for a children’s playground than a grown-up narrative. I expected sharp repartee but instead encountered immature squabbles that often felt more cringe-worthy than entertaining.
One of the most irritating aspects of this book was its structure. The narrative relied heavily on repetition, cycling through the same thoughts and perspectives without adding any new insights. Hearing Micah bemoan her circumstances, followed by Aiden’s lengthy rants, only to have the situation retold in a modern-day Shakespearean style, became a daunting chore. Once was enough—I didn’t need to endure it three times.
As for the pranks, they promised the kind of cleverness one might admire in books like The Hating Game or You Deserve Each Other, yet they fell horrendously short. The juvenile nature of their antics left me shaking my head in disbelief rather than laughing along. I found myself wishing for some originality, for anything beyond petty and uninspired tactics.
Moving to the audiobook, which featured narrators Cindy Kay and J.F. Harding, I was disappointed once again. Kay has graced us with excellent performances in the past, but her work here felt disjointed. Meanwhile, Harding’s narration was merely adequate; there were moments when I struggled to discern which character was speaking. The lack of cohesion between the two narrators added a level of frustration to my experience, hindering my enjoyment even further.
While I appreciate the attempt to explore serious themes like job loss and personal turmoil, Micah’s reaction to her situation often bordered on melodrama. The character seemed to lean into victimhood rather than seeking constructive solutions, making it challenging to sympathize with her. And just when I thought the characters would mature, their ultimate confrontation echoed the immature tone of the rest of the book—both disappointing and lackluster.
In conclusion, despite its intriguing premise that suggested potential for wit and warmth, Much Ado About Hating You ultimately felt lifeless and uninspired. If you’re drawn to academic romances and enjoy a light read filled with some absurd pranks, perhaps you could find some entertainment here. However, for readers seeking authentic chemistry, sharp banter, and engaging character development, I would recommend looking elsewhere. I certainly wish I had. My overall experience was a reminder of the importance of character depth and narrative flow in crafting a truly memorable story—elements that, sadly, were lost amidst the pages of this one.
Discover more about Much Ado About Hating You on GoodReads >>