How to Keep House While Drowning: A Reflection on Comfort, Chaos, and Cleanliness
When I first heard about How to Keep House While Drowning by Marianne Ilardi, I was intrigued. A book that promises to address the struggles of maintaining a clean home amid life’s chaos? It seemed like it could either be a lifesaver or a recipe for further frustration. Given my own challenges with tidiness (which I might be more comfortable facing head-on than coddling), I dove in with a mix of hope and skepticism. Spoiler: it didn’t quite float my boat.
From the outset, it felt like this book was more tailored for parents than for anyone else, and I’m not one of them. While I completely understand the struggles of juggling responsibilities, I found the focus on parenting alienating. That said, there were indeed nuggets of wisdom that transcended the target demographic, particularly when Ilardi asserts that "cleanliness is not next to godliness." Yes, amen to that! A clean house does not define one’s moral character, something I wish more people realized. I’ve witnessed this firsthand with a family member who battles ADHD and depression; their home might be cluttered, but their kindness and creativity shine through.
Ilardi also challenges readers to rethink their relationship with their living spaces, which is a refreshing perspective. The idea that "your spaces serve you" encapsulated a mindset shift I wholeheartedly support. It encourages self-examination about what truly serves our lives, allowing us to carve out more time for what brings joy or peace.
However, as I traversed through the pages, I was struck by a tone that felt overly permissive. The suggestion to hit the “easy button” at every hurdle contrasted starkly with my own belief that life’s challenges demand engagement rather than retreat. Yes, mental health struggles are real, and I can appreciate that sweeping decisions may sometimes feel insurmountable. Yet at various points, How to Keep House While Drowning read like a gentle nudge to step back instead of tackling life head-on, which didn’t resonate with my own approach. Sometimes, we have to push through the hard stuff, whether it’s folding laundry or tackling emotional hurdles.
And then, there were the environmental issues, which left me scratching my head. Recommending disposable items when we’re all trying to reduce waste feels counterintuitive. While Ilardi’s sentiments about prioritizing mental health are valid, throwing plastic into the mix felt more anxiety-inducing than liberating to me.
Ultimately, while How to Keep House While Drowning presents some valid points, it was not the right fit for me. If you’re someone who thrives on gentle encouragement, perhaps you’ll find comfort here. But if you, like me, believe in facing challenges head-on and tackling the hard stuff, this book might feel too indulgent.
In the end, I admire Ilardi’s effort to reach out to those who may be struggling with domestic chaos, and though this book didn’t resonate with me, I wish it well on its journey. After all, every reader deserves to find what helps them thrive, and I’m just here to share my piece of the puzzle.
Discover more about How to Keep House While Drowning on GoodReads >>